DodgerBlast: Spring Training Roster Analysis
After opening the Spring camp with an 8-3 win, it’s time to jump into the YKI Analysis of each of the players either on or contending for a spot on the 25-man roster that will break Camp

The rest of Spring augurs well for the Dodgers, who despite the lack of a big-name addition, still have one of the stronger core groups in MLB. With the exception of the battle for the fourth (and fifth?) outfield slot, as well as the heated competition for the role of fifth starter, the young nucleus + Manny still should enable the Dodgers to remain a top contender for the NL Pennant.

More on that from YKI down the road, but for now, YKI dissects the Roster:
STARTING PITCHERS KershawWill finally turn 22 this year, and already a dominant force. Kept on a very short leash thus far in his major league career by Torre/Honeycutt, Kershaw will be given more leniency this year as the de facto Ace. The lefty has been compared to Sandy Koufax, and his brief-yet-excellent tenure thus far portends positively. That mantle may be a bit too much for a third-year pitcher to carry, though Kershaw’s mature outlook and quiet confidenc belies his youth, and he should end the year amongst the elite arms in the league. Billingsley – A very frustrating pitcher from the perspective of the fan (and organization). There is no question about his ability or his ‘stuff’ – the lingering concern is about his mentality/approach, and based on his late-season (and playoff) shortcomings the past few years, little hope is offered for his ability to really embrace the role of Ace. Billingsley is slated to be the ersatz Ace this season, as Kershaw is only 22, and may be one of the more dominant two starters down the road. He is only 25, however, and many great pitchers haven’t reached their prime years until their late 20’s. Could potentially be Cain to Kershaw’s Lincecum. Kuroda – Though only a .500 pitcher in his two years as a Dodger, Kuroda is a very consistent and effective pitcher. Not much of a strikeout threat, he does one thing well – get outs. His WHIP has been in the NL Top Ten both of his years, and with the exception of the line drive he took off the face last year, he is a stalwart pitcher, and one of the best third starters in the League. Padilla – The maligned and misunderstood Padilla showed last year why he was a feared & underrated pitcher in the American League. Accusations of ‘being a jerk,’ were bandied about, as he was disliked and eschewed by teammates, forcing him out of the Rangers organization and thusly providing a coup for Ned Colletti, who acquired the Nicarauguan for a can of beans last season. The point is, Padilla – as sweaty as they come – is a gamer, and battles incessantly. He gives the Dodgers a great chance to win, and as a former All-Star, is capable of being a number two starter for many teams. For the Dodgers to have him in the Fourth slot is an overlooked advantage, especially come time for the pennant race. Stults/Charlie Haeger/James McDonald/Ramon Ortiz/Scott Elbert/Russ Ortiz/The Ghost of Kevin GrossStults is the long-term favorite, having been up-and-down in the organization for a few years; Elbert is the former prospect that may have peaked in the minors, destined for a AAAA status career; McDonald has the most talent and was on the post-season roster and is YKI’s selection, but has been marred by control issues which always will doom a starting pitcher; the Ortiz boys have both had success in the bigs, and though Russ played for the Panorama City American Legion team half a decade prior to YKI, does not appear to have much left at the big league level; Haeger is YKI’s favorite, but a knuckleballer does not stand a chance if Torre & Honeycutt have their druthers – he may be the last man standing, and will be productive if so, but will most likely have to catch on elsewhere.

BULLPEN WeaverWeaver was a former Ace, and aside from the tragic time in New York, has shown flashes of brilliance everywhere. That said, his Xbox-attention span and shoulder-slumping behavior derailed his career at each locale. Relegated to minor league camp and bouncing between organziations, Weaver rededicated himself to the game last offseason and paid season-long dividends to Torre & the Dodgers, filling every role possible from long-reliver to spot starter. Perhaps the most valuable member of the pitching staff, the Simi Valley native needs to be productive again for the Dodgers to win the division. BelisarioThe rookie was leaned on heavily by Torre last year, and understandably so. Proving to be reliable – and at times, dominant – he was a key member of the bullpen, and should be again in 2010, provided his visa issues clear up and allow him to return to the United States. GagneGame Over returns, though minus the performance-enhancing substances. Not a lock to make the club, YKI would thoroughly enjoy a renaissance from Gagne, if for no other reason than he is so darn fun to watch. WadeOverworked by Torre during his solid rookie season, Wade spent much of 2009 injured, but should bounce back as an effective 7th inning reliever. TroncosoNot exactly a game-changer, Troncoso nonetheless received the ball three times per week from Torre. Solid at times, Troncoso is not necessarily a favorite of YKI. KuoThe ultimate rebounder, Kuo has returned from four (!?!?) arm surgeries, and is still electric, perhaps now more than ever. When healthy, Kuo is darn near unhittable. . .but that’s a big ‘when’ and if, because Kuo is a threat to have his career end with each pitch. SherrillDoppleganger to Jeff Kent personality-wise, is at least effective as a left-handed set-up man. YKI is still not sold on his potential to dominate (Orioles closer? Really?), but was effective last year. Keep an eye on him, though – YKI senses a bit of Brian Fuentes/Eddie Guardado in the reliever. BroxtonAptly nicknamed “Cannibal,” Brox quite literally eats opposing hitters with his fastball. Perhaps the hardest thrower in baseball, the only concern about the Dodgers closer is his mentality – does he have the fortitude to close for an entire (post)season? Hopefully the Cannibal’s appetite is hearty this year, as he should get around 50+ opportunities.
CATCHERS MartinBeefed up for 2010, Martin had somewhat of a disappointing year both offensively & defensively in 2009. Worried about his declining power numbers, he added 25 pounds of muscle in one (?!?) season, and looks to return to All-Star form. The Dodgers absolutely need a good season out of ‘The Muscle’ if they are to contend for the pennant. AusmusThe Ivy Leaguer decided to strap it on for one more season, and the Dodgers coaching staff & youngsters are quite pleased. A savvy veteran that will only appear in 40+ games, he’s a player that accepts his role and utilizes his knowledge to gain his competitive advantage. Great roster guy and future big league manager. EllisWorking man’s backup with talent caught in a logjam (read: deadend) behind the young stud and veteran leader, will only appear if injuries occur. If that should happen, he’ll gain valuable experience to become starter and potential star elsewhere.

INFIELD LoneyNot quite a star yet, YKI forsees a breakout year for the lanky first baseman. A pure hitter and natural gloveman, Loney is now turning 26 years old, meaning he’s about to enter his prime. That sweet swing will produce more longballs than in previous years, and he’ll hit above .300. Should be a year away from All-Stardom. BelliardAlmost good enough last year to supplant Orlando Hudson in the minds of Dodgers fans (in addition to the lineup of Torre), Belliard provides great pop from the second base position, and is solid enough in the field to contribute positively. Loves the game, and has great chemistry with Furcal. DeWittOn the verge of becoming the infield version of Jason Repko, DeWitt is a fan favorite for his out-of-nowhere rise to competence as starting third baseman from opening day a couple years ago. Since then, he’s foundered in the organization, bouncing between Las Vegas and Los Angeles in search for meaningful at-bats. FurcalFurcal is back, and healthy. This is a very good thing for the Dodgers, as Furcal is the engine of the offense, and the captain of the defense. When 100%, Furcal is amongst the best shortstops in the game, bringing speed, a natural hitting stroke and most importantly for the Dodgers, a passion for the game. Blake“The Beard” is no more, but Blake is still going to bring his lunchpail and hardhat every day. Count on Casey for .267+, 20 bombs and 75+ RBIs as well as a steady bat and a workmanlike mentality. CarrollYKI isn’t quite sure why the Dodgers acquired this journeyman aside from the bargain basement price tag. Never one to hit for power – or average, for that matter – at 36 years old, he does not possess much upside either. Hu/Alfred Amezaga/Nick Green/Ivan DeJesusCompeting for the role of Jose Vizcaino, Hu is the typical 4A player, though still young; Amezaga is versatile and will play a role prior to the season’s end; Green had a breakout year for the Red Sox last year but won’t get much of a look; DeJesus is young and bursting with potential but won’t see much playing time.

OUTFIELD RamirezDrugs or not, Manny is a fan favorite, and will prove that last year’s second half debacle was a fluke. YKI is not expecting a return to 35+ HR, but a reasonable .285, 29hr and 99 RBI should be expected, and enough to warrant a happy farewell tour around the City of Dodgers. KempKemp is being portrayed as The Next Big Thing (GQ Magazine?!?!), but isn’t quite ready to attain the 40/40 season some are predicting for him. His rapid ascent to All-Stardom last year surprised even Joe Torre, and he may have one more ‘very good’ year before catapulting to true superstardom. EthierThe surly and irritable Ethier was the Dodgers offensive MVP last year, and is bent on still being an A-hole. That’s not a concern of YKI, though, as he hit his way into a guaranteed job coming out of Spring for the first time in his career, and also won more games than any player in the big leagues. At 28 years old, Ethier will be a stalwart in the middle of the Dodgers lineup for years to come. Anderson – YKI’s sentimental favorite, the Valley native is a non-roster invitee, and will hopefully win the Jim Thome role of lefty of the bench. Anderson has 2,501 career hits and could chase 3,000 as a DH in the AL, but wanted to come back home and have a chance to win the World Series again. Here’s hoping he does. GilesFormerly a good player. Now, too old. RepkoAfter numerous incarnations as 25th man on the Dodgers roster, now is his time to prove he can stick around. If not, can go be a Cody Ross for a second tier team. JohnsonThough YKI was initially sour on this signing, it seems Johnson’s game is suitable for the role of fourth outfielder as he can hit a little bit, run a little bit and field a little bit.



  1. dodgerduncan

    well done. I like the acquisition of johnson, he’s a sparkplug and has a good attitude. furcal being healthy is key for the dodgers. i am not too sure about billingsley’s future here, tho. he may have worn out his welcome.

  2. ochocinco85

    This team didn’t do much to make themselves better. Good thing the rest of the NL West is young and not much better than mediocre, they will probably win the division. Manny is too old.

  3. DodgerZeyboy

    The Dodgers have as strong of a lineup as anybody in the National League. I’m not sure they’re going to challenge for the pennant without an ace, though. Billingsley and Kershaw could be the best duo in the league but both are young and like you say, Billingsley’s mentality is unproven. I don’t like Padilla much, and Kuroda is a throwaway, if he even can recover from the injury. For the lineup, Blake is older than people realize and if he and Furcal play old (or hurt) then they will be completely void on the left side of the infield. Belliard is a fat turd but Loney can smack. The outfield will be strong, though don’t expect much from Manny. Great bullpen. Should be a fun season.

  4. Bob Harrigan

    Brian Giles has a lifetime OBA of .400. You know how RARE that is? I looked it up. The only other Dodgers to end thier careers with an OBA of 400+ are

    Lefty O’Doul, the HOF LF from the 30s who finished his amazing Career with a sparkling .413 OBA.

    Eddie Stanky, the Brooklyn 3B who drove pitchers CRAZY fouling off pitch after pitch, only to draw a walk. His Lifetime BA is like .255, but his OBA is .405.

    Jackie Robinson, the “Handsome brown-eyed man” himself, was a gamer at the plate and knew how to win that battle, as demonstrated by his astonishing .409 lifetime OBA.

    Gary Sheffield, the borderline HOF player who was, until we picked up Manny, the best hitter ever to play for the LOS ANGELES verson of the Dodgers has a lifetime OBA of .424

    And of course, Manny, who right now has an OBA of a freakish .442

    That’s it. Those are the only Dodgers to have an OBA of .400 at the end of their careers. And now Brian Giles.

    The ability NOT to make an out is HUGE, especially during RALLIES, when he is most expected to be up.

    The ability not to hit into DPs is also key for a pinch hitter.

    Brian Giles has, in his career, hit into a total of 160, while Garrett Anderson has hit into 191.

    Garrett Andersons OBA is .326 compared to Giles’s .400. That’s 74 points difference.

    Still not convinced?

    How about slugging%? GA: 465. Brian Giles? 502.

    Stolen Bases? GA: 79 Brian Giles: 109

    2008: GA hit .293 with an OBA of .325 and 15 Jacks.

    Brian Giles hit .303, OBA of .398, and 12 Jacks.

    They’re basically the same player, except Giles is better in every category by a little bit and has a HUGE advantage in OBA.

    “Too old” you say? Okay, maybe, Giles is 18 months older than Garrett, and Brian had short, bad year last year. Injuries heal though, and He’s in great –cover of some muscle magazine– shape.

    Garrett is from Granada Hills, and played at Kennedy, so thats fun. But they’re both So Cal kids. Giles is from El Cajon, and I banged a sorority girl from El Cajon, so there.

  5. Bob Harrigan

    Broxton should be a starter.

    We have too much in the pen as it is.

    The whole “Stopper” thing is overrated.

    Broxton has an INCREDIBLE arm, throwing 100 MPH regularly. He should start. We’d get 180 innings out of him and 17 wins. Out of the pen he needs to be measured against his opportunity cost. In other words, how much worse off would we be with KUO as the closer? How much BETTER would we be with BROXTON every 5 days, instead of ….whoever starting? JUST PICTURE That: JONATHAN BROXTON…winds up….first pitch of the game….BLAMMO! STRIKE! 100 MPH! Hows THAT for some shit? Talk about SENDING THE FRIGGIN MESSAGE! I’d love to storm into SAN FRANCISCO WITH THAT SHIT…THAT’ll shut those bastards up. STRIKE OUT THE SIDE to start it off in the first…. nice.

    If not that, then he should be used as a classic “FIREMAN”, since he strikes batters out so much. Striking guys out to start off the 9th is a waste of a strikeout. You only need to strikeout a batter when there are guys on and a big hitter up. The Fireman role should be used in baseball. It used to be. The whole “Game Over” thing is total fan-based WWE Bullshit.

  6. Countthechips

    Well done! Hope springs eternal. The Dodgers have potential. A bunch of young players looking to get better.

  7. Bob Harrigan

    Wasn’t it Broxton, who in 2008, gave up a homer to end our season?

    And wasn’t it also Broxton who, in 2009, gave up a triple to end our season?


    Make him a starter. He can’t take the pressure of relieving in big games.

  8. Bob Harrigan

    Oh, I forgot to make a prediction:

    Russell Martin will be injury plagued this year because he believes that a catcher needs to “Bulk up” in order to be strong.

    He’s lugging around 25 extra pounds that do nothing but slow him down and wear him down even faster.

    That groin pull would have been great evidence to back up my prediciton, but who cares? I’ll use it anyway. “The groin pull is evidence that Russell Martin is out of shape” There. I said it.

  9. Countthechips

    If the young players keep improving, the Dodgers will surprise a lot of people this year! Go Blue!!!!

  10. Pingback: Bonsignore, Consigliere « YallKiltIt – Sports from an L.A. State of Mind
  11. Pingback: Billingsley: Ace? « YKI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s